TY - JOUR AU - Rhein, Valérie PY - 2020/09/10 Y2 - 2024/03/28 TI - Law, Hierarchy, and Gender: Reflections on the Exemption of Women from Time-Bound Commandments JF - Judaica. Neue digitale Folge JA - JNDF VL - 1 IS - 0 SE - Artikel DO - 10.36950/jndf.1.4 UR - https://judaica.ch/article/view/1.4 SP - AB - <p>Why do the <em>tannaim</em> exempt women from time-bound commandments (m. Qiddushin 1:7)? In this paper it is argued that the unequal levels of obligation for men and women in rabbinic Judaism creates a hierarchy of mitzvot between them that mimics and virtually replaces the earlier biblical hierarchy of mitzvot between priests and Israel. In both constellations the rabbis consider the obligation to fulfill more commandments to be a privilege. The similarity between the hierarchies priests–Israel and men–women becomes apparent when the selection of commandments from which the <em>tannaim</em> and the <em>amoraim</em> explicitly exempt women are examined more closely: Many of them – the time-bound commandments <em>shofar, lulav, tzitzit, tefillin</em>, and <em>shema</em> as well as the non-time-bound mitzvah of Torah study – share a common feature, namely, their function as “ersatz Temple rituals.” During the transition from a Temple-oriented, priest-based Judaism to a study-oriented rabbinic Judaism, rituals such as these played a crucial role.</p> ER -